Water utility tells Bluffton residents brown water is safe to drink. Many have doubts. | Hilton Head

Water utility tells Bluffton residents brown water is protected to drink. Many have doubts. | Hilton Head

BLUFFTON — When Katrina Pannazzo moved right here 20 years in the past, the city was house to simply 2,371 individuals. And when she turned on her faucet, she might depend on the water working clear.

At this time, she shares the city with 32,000 different residents. And when she activates her faucet to wash her kids, cook dinner dinner or pour a glass to drink, generally the water comes out clear. Different instances, it runs yellow, yellowish-brown or, on a latest event, dark-brown.

Pannazzo stated the problem began about 4 years in the past, and it appears to occur a minimum of as soon as each different month. 

“Truthfully, I want we might transfer,” Pannazzo stated. “However our mortgage is so comfy, I would hate to maneuver.” 

Water utility tells Bluffton residents brown water is protected to drink.

Within the neighboring metropolis of Hardeeville, residents have additionally seen their inhabitants improve dramatically. Prior to now decade it went up practically 200 p.c, from 2,952 individuals in 2010 as much as practically 9,000 in the latest census.

Each Hardeeville and Bluffton are serviced by the Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewage Authority, whose employees have voiced concern over the utility’s capacity to maintain up with the ever-increasing demand for water.

One factor they’re assured about is the security of the water. The discoloration, customer support operators and different firm representatives have assured prospects, is merely an aesthetics subject.

Nonetheless, many residents have reservations about consuming yellow or brown water. 


A tub stuffed with faucet water within the Heritage at New Riverside neighborhood in Bluffton is pictured on Dec. 22, 2022. Katrina Pannazzo/Supplied  

Emily McIsaac lives within the New Riverside part of city, not removed from Pannazzo, in a 365-acre group of single-family houses surrounded by salt marsh, hardwood forest and fast growth. She turned so pissed off with the water high quality, she put in an expensive whole-house filtration system in her house.

The producer of McIsaac’s water filter, Categorical Water, whose programs value as much as $500 plus set up, advises prospects that the filter ought to stay comparatively clear to ensure that the system to operate correctly. Filters, the corporate advertises, are usually good for about six months. 

On Nov. 7, McIsaac put a brand new filter in her household’s filtration system. By Nov. 9, it was dark-brown and stuffed with sediment.

When The Publish and Courier introduced her case to the eye of the water utility, Pamela Flasch, director of public affairs, supplied a reality sheet explaining that phosphates added to the water as a corrosion inhibitor will trigger the filter to clog and switch brown. Because of this, the filter won’t final so long as the producer advertises. 

In McIsaac’s case, her filter’s shelf life was reduce from six months to 2 days.

“Is BJWSA going to reimburse us for the additional value of extra frequent filter adjustments?” stated Jeff Maultsby, one other New Riverside resident who felt compelled to put in a whole-house filtration system in his house. “The filters are alleged to be good for 100,000 gallons. Not in Bluffton although.” 


“I’ve to vary my water filter at my home each few weeks.” Jeff Maultsby stated at his house within the New Riverside group in Bluffton on Wednesday, Jan. 11, 2023. He stated the filter ought to final for 100,000 gallons and usually doesn’t should be modified for a couple of 12 months. Andrew J. Whitaker/Employees

Therapy capability 

The utility says the problem just isn’t a scarcity of water. Somewhat, it’s its capability to deal with the water and get it out into the system. 

At the moment, the Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewage Authority has 65,000 connections serving 171,000 South Carolinians. It’s seeing a progress price of three,000 new connections per 12 months.

In a city planning session on Nov. 16, Brian Chemsak, chief of plant operations, notified Bluffton City Council that the utility has failed to remain forward of the water demand.  

“We’re in a little bit little bit of a center house, of not having fairly sufficient capability however having issues within the works that can tackle it,” he stated. 

The utility’s water withdrawal allow permits it to take as much as 99 million gallons of water per day from the Savannah River, Beaufort and Jasper counties’ major water supply. In line with Chemsak, that’s greater than sufficient to satisfy demand. 

“The availability just isn’t an element. It actually comes right down to our remedy capability is presently what our limiting issue is,” Chemsak stated. 

At the moment, the utility is ready to deal with as much as 39 million gallons per day, at two totally different vegetation: the Chelsea Water Therapy Plant and the Purrysburg Plant. 

Within the winter, the demand is simply about 18-19 million gallons per day. Between its two remedy vegetation, the utility ought to have the capability to satisfy wintertime demand.

In the summertime, the utility’s peak day referred to as for 34.9 million gallons of water, which also needs to fall inside the utility’s day by day remedy capability of 39 million gallons.

The problem, based on Chemsak, comes through the peak hours of three to 9 a.m. At the moment, individuals irrigate their grass extra often, particularly in deed-restricted communities, the place owners face fines for not sustaining a wholesome garden.  

“Each day, we’re producing sufficient water to produce the demand. However throughout these peak instances, we’re not capable of sustain,” he stated. 

Throughout peak summertime hours, Chemsak estimated the demand is equal to 55 million gallons per day, sufficient to overwhelm each remedy vegetation.

“What this can lead to is reverse in circulation in our pipes, as water is used to going in a single path, and there is a giant demand in one other space, which ends up in stress loss at individuals’s houses and discoloration. And, in the end, the worst-case situation could be a boil-water advisory,” Chemsak stated.

Ought to the water stress within the pipes fall to twenty kilos per sq. inch or beneath, a boil-water advisory could be wanted. Chemsak stated that on some mornings, the stress is 23-24 kilos per sq. inch in some components of the system.

He added, “We have not had any boil-water advisories in our system attributable to this demand. Nevertheless, we monitor it day by day.” 

Despite enormous growth, Bluffton is trying to hang on to its small-town charm

In the meanwhile, the utility is instituting a “provide hole resolution,” wherein residents, companies and landscapers are requested to assist flatten peak morning demand by adjusting irrigation schedules. 

When The Publish and Courier requested why, if the utility has pinpointed the problem to the summer season months, residents are reporting discolored water 12 months spherical, representatives for the utility responded in an e mail, “Demand is far decrease within the wintertime, however localized demand spikes might be attributable to a wide range of elements together with important breaks, service line breaks, firefighting, close by testing, building, deliberate plant upkeep and plenty of different circumstances.”

Mistrust within the utility 

With so many ranging explanations, the utility has misplaced the belief of some Bluffton residents. 

On Dec. 22, two days earlier than a Christmas Eve freeze disrupted water service throughout the state, the water in New Riverside got here out wanting like espresso. 

“That is the primary time I’ve seen it that dangerous,” Pannazzo stated.


A glass of faucet water from a house on April 25, 2020, in Bluffton. Katrina Pannazzo/Supplied

When she and her neighbors referred to as the utility’s buyer assist line to report the problem, they got a large number of causes for the discoloration: Development employees had tapped right into a mainline. They had been conducting a water-quality flushing. It was an issue with the home-owner’s water heater.

“They’re reactive once we name, versus being proactive to the problem,” Pannazzo stated. 

Regardless of the discoloration, every customer support consultant assured prospects the water was protected to drink. 

In an e mail to the newspaper two weeks after the incident, the utility attributed the discoloration to fireside hydrants, which had been being examined for operational use.

Representatives for the corporate defined how minerals, primarily manganese and iron, gathered within the pipes. When the hearth hydrants had been examined, the water stress launched the manganese and iron into the water, inflicting the discoloration. As soon as the brown water was within the system, the hydrants needed to be left on till all of it was flushed out.

At no level, they assured residents, was the water unsafe to devour. 

“Once we name, particularly once we all name on the identical day, we are going to get differing causes for the problem. In order that makes everyone involved. Do they actually know what it’s? Are they actually monitoring it? Or are they only type of throwing totally different explanations out for what it may very well be?” Pannazzo stated.

“No matter it’s, we should not should take care of it,” Maultsby stated.

The lack of belief within the water firm has induced some residents to attract parallels between the discolored water and their well being points.

Dusty Lee is a disabled Air Drive veteran who lives in Bluffton. Whereas he was within the service, he developed a pores and skin situation after being uncovered to a gasoline spill. Though medical doctors have been unable to verify it, he and his spouse consider the water has infected his situation. 

Pannazzo’s household suffers power abdomen aches. When she, her husband and their youngest son all get upset stomachs on the similar time, they pour water right into a white cup to test the colour. 

“We nearly know it is discolored or there’s one thing within the water earlier than we even see it as a result of we’ll all begin feeling yucky,” she stated.  

Similar to Lee, Pannazzo and her household have but to get a health care provider to verify their well being points are associated to the water. 

“There should not be something in our water that is giving anybody abdomen aches, as a result of we at all times meet or exceed our necessities, federal and state,” Flasch stated.

Her assertion was backed up by the latest water high quality report, which was performed by an impartial lab and confirmed that Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewage Authority had, in actual fact, met or exceeded Environmental Safety Company requirements. 

St. Helena Island doesn’t want to be Hilton Head. Now, a developer is proposing a golf resort

Flasch attributed the brown water to manganese. 

“It is the manganese within the water and we’re working to treatment that. We’ve a several-year examine and a program of motion that we will be utilizing to handle the manganese and the iron within the system, which tends to gather in sure areas. After which when there’s directional flushing, right here it comes. So we will be taking a look at methods to alleviate that,” Flasch stated. 

On the latest water-quality report, each manganese and iron had been developing at “beneath detectible ranges.”

When requested why, if manganese was the reason for the discoloration, it was not displaying up on the water exams, the utility responded in an e mail, “The water accommodates a small quantity of manganese (beneath .05 mg/l), this quantity over time accumulates on the pipe partitions and might contribute to discolored water. House testing kits could or could not be capable to detect manganese at or beneath this stage.” 

DRONE AERIAL Bluffton_4.jpg Growth subdivision

Residents of the New Riverside group in Bluffton are routinely seeing brown water come out of their taps. Andrew J. Whitaker/Employees

Powerless towards progress

Pannazzo’s frustrations are usually not restricted to the water firm. “It is also irritating that the city is ignoring the problem and plowing forward with constructing at an uncontrolled price, when everybody is aware of the infrastructure is not maintaining,” she stated. 

However the city of Bluffton, in lots of circumstances, is contractually obligated to permit the expansion to proceed, regardless of how a lot of a pressure it locations on sources. 

From 1852, when Bluffton was first included, up till 1998, the city was made up of just one sq. mile. Then, in 1998, Palmetto Bluff annexed into the city, bringing with it 20,000 acres of land and 4,000 entitled homesites. In a single day, the city went from being simply 1 sq. mile to over 32 sq. miles.


A number of plumbing vehicles are seen within the New Riverside group in Bluffton on Wednesday, Jan. 11, 2023. Andrew J. Whitaker/Employees

As a deliberate unit growth, Palmetto Bluff has zoning and growth guidelines that aren’t ruled by the city. Somewhat, the foundations are dictated by a growth contract that was in place earlier than Palmetto Bluff was annexed. The native authorities is obligated to honor the contract or it might face a lawsuit. 

“Stopping growth just isn’t the main target, as a result of that ship sailed a very long time in the past,” stated city Councilwoman Bridgette Frazier. 

Bluffton now consists of 54 sq. miles. The overwhelming majority of that land mass — 92 p.c — falls inside a deliberate unit growth. Of the agreements in place, 80 p.c of residential and 36 p.c of nonresidential agreements have been constructed out. 

Signe Gardo closes iconic Hilton Head bakery after 50 years and over 4,000 wedding cakes

Water just isn’t the one public service strained underneath the load of all the expansion. The varsity system is overcrowded. There is a trainer scarcity and an inexpensive housing disaster. Visitors accidents are on the rise. 

“We see a big quantity of visitors accidents within the city. And that simply goes with we see extra vehicles on the roadways,” stated Police Chief Joseph Babkiewicz. 

Even the pure sources, just like the Could River, cherished by so many within the city, are in jeopardy. 

At any time when Kim Jones, director of initiatives and watershed resilience for Bluffton, provides a presentation to group membership, she begins off by asking how many individuals within the room are native Blufftonians. 

“Perhaps a hand, in the event you’re fortunate, goes up within the crowd,” she stated. 

Subsequent she’s going to ask what number of within the room are native to South Carolina. 

“I would get a pair few that go up,” she stated. 

With the inflow of latest residents, native sources and utilities are left making an attempt to play catch-up. 

As a long-term resolution, Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewage Authority has earmarked $52 million to take the capability of the Purrysburg Water Therapy Plant up from 15 million to 30 million gallons per day. Officers anticipate building to be accomplished by 2025. 

As soon as the plant is upgraded, the utility can have a mixed capability to deal with 54 million gallons per day. That might nonetheless depart them 1 million gallons shy of their peak summer season day in 2022.

And if the expansion price continues at 3,000 new connections per 12 months, by the point the Purrysburg enlargement is full, the discoloration subject will likely be compounded by a fair larger demand for water. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *